Buyers Guide to Choosing the Right Olive Oil - Rallis Natural Living Blog

Your Comprehensive Guide to Olive Oil Types, Grading, and Selection


As you embark on your journey through the olive oil aisle at your local grocery store, it's essential to understand the array of options available. The sheer variety of olive oils can be overwhelming, with choices like extra virgin, virgin, pure, light, and even ice-pressed olive oil. To help you navigate this selection and make an informed choice tailored to your culinary and health preferences, let's dive into the world of olive oil and explore its various types.

Types of Olive Oil

  • Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO).  Extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) stands as the pinnacle of olive oils. It's made from the first cold press of olives, without exposure to heat or chemicals. This results in an oil with delicate flavors, low acidity, and exceptional nutritional value. EVOO is known for its fruity, grassy, and sometimes slightly peppery taste, making it perfect for drizzling over salads, dipping bread, or adding a finishing touch to dishes.
  • Virgin Olive Oil.  Virgin olive oil is also unrefined and free from heat or chemicals during extraction but has slightly higher acidity than extra virgin. It offers a milder flavor profile and is a versatile choice for cooking and baking without overpowering other flavors.
  • Pure Olive Oil.  Pure olive oil, often labeled as "olive oil" or "classic olive oil," is a blend of virgin and refined olive oils. Refined olive oil undergoes further processing to remove impurities and is then blended with virgin oil to restore some of its flavor.
  • Light Olive Oil.  Despite its name, light olive oil doesn't have fewer calories or less fat. It's a refined olive oil with a mild, neutral flavor, making it suitable for cooking without dominating the taste of other ingredients. Keep in mind that it may have fewer health benefits compared to extra virgin or virgin olive oil due to some nutrient loss during refining.

Organic Olive Oil Classification

Organic olive oil is produced from olives grown without synthetic pesticides, herbicides, or fertilizers. It follows the same production process as other olive oils but with a focus on sustainable and eco-friendly farming practices. To be classified as organic, olive oil must meet specific certifications and standards, ensuring the integrity of its organic claim.

Some of the key certifications include:

  • USDA Organic: In the United States, the USDA Organic seal is a well-known certification for organic products, including olive oil. To earn this label, olive oil producers must adhere to strict guidelines, demonstrating that their olives are cultivated without the use of synthetic chemicals.
  • European Union Organic: Within the European Union, organic olive oil is certified according to EU regulations. Producers must comply with rigorous standards regarding organic farming methods, avoiding chemical pesticides and promoting sustainability.
  • IFOAM Organic Certification: The International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM) sets global standards for organic agriculture. Olive oil with the IFOAM Organic Certification ensures that it meets international organic farming principles, emphasizing environmental sustainability and natural farming practices.
  • Ecocert Certification: Ecocert is another respected certification body that offers organic certification for olive oil and various other products. Olive oil with Ecocert Certification signifies compliance with their stringent organic farming and processing standards.
  • Third-Party Organic Certifiers: Additionally, various third-party organizations offer organic certifications. These organizations conduct inspections and audits to confirm that olive oil producers meet the required organic criteria. Look for certifications from well-respected third-party certifiers to ensure the authenticity of the organic olive oil you choose.

These certifications serve as guarantees that the olive oil you're considering is indeed organic, cultivated in an environmentally friendly manner, and free from synthetic chemicals, providing you with a trustworthy choice for your culinary and health needs.

Cold-Pressed vs. Ice-Pressed® Olive Oil

Cold-Pressed olive oil is made by mechanically pressing olives at temperatures below 27°C (80°F). This gentle process helps retain the oil's flavor and nutritional value. It can encompass various olive oil categories, such as extra virgin or virgin. Look for the specific type of cold-pressed oil you desire on the label.

Ice-pressed® olive oil is a unique variety that involves an extraction process using cold temperatures to maintain the oil's quality and flavor. The olives are pressed at even lower temperatures than cold-pressed olive oil, resulting in a product with a distinct taste and remarkable freshness. Ice-pressed® olive oil is gaining popularity for its exceptional quality and flavor, making it a delightful addition to culinary creations and a great choice for health-conscious consumers.

These separate sections provide a detailed insight into organic olive oil and the distinction between cold-pressed and ice-pressed® olive oils, helping you make informed decisions about which variety best suits your preferences and needs.

Now that you've explored the diverse types of olive oil available, from the exquisite extra virgin to the unique ice-pressed variety, it's time to delve into how these oils are classified and graded. Understanding the grading criteria is essential to make informed choices about the quality and characteristics of olive oil, ensuring you pick the right one for your culinary needs and preferences. Let's transition to the next section, where we'll unravel the grading system for olive oil and its significance in selecting the finest options.

Olive Oil Grading 

USDA Grading

In the United States, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) has established a grading system for olive oil quality.

The grades include:

US Extra Virgin Olive Oil (EVOO): The highest quality with no defects and less than 0.8% free acidity.

US Virgin Olive Oil: Slightly lower quality but still with good flavor and aroma, and acidity below 2%.

US Olive Oil: A blend of pure and light olive oil with acidity below 1%.

US Olive-Pomace Oil: Lower quality and not included in the USDA's grades, as it's extracted using solvents and heat.

International Standards

The International Olive Council (IOC) sets global standards for olive oil quality. Categories include:

Extra Virgin Olive Oil: The highest quality with no defects and less than 0.8% free acidity.

Virgin Olive Oil: Like the USDA's definition, with slightly higher acidity levels, up to 2%.

Refined Olive Oil: Made by treating low-quality virgin olive oil with solvents and heat, then blended with virgin olive oil to restore flavor.

Olive Oil: Comparable to the U.S. Olive Oil, including both pure and light olive oils.

Olive-Pomace Oil: Recognized but considered lower in quality. 

Now that you've gained insights into the intricate grading system for olive oil, it's time to put this knowledge to practical use in selecting the perfect olive oil for your kitchen. Understanding the various grades and attributes of olive oil will empower you to make well-informed decisions.

In the next section, we'll provide you with valuable tips on how to choose the right olive oil, considering factors like flavor, origin, and budget, ensuring that your culinary creations are enriched with the finest quality olive oil tailored to your preferences.

Selecting the Right Olive Oil

Choosing the perfect olive oil can be a nuanced process. Follow these tips to make the right selection:

  • Opt for Dark Bottles. High-quality olive oil is sensitive to light and air, which can lead to deterioration. Choose olive oils in dark glass or opaque bottles to shield the oil from harmful UV rays.
  • Check the Harvest Date A good olive oil should display the harvest date on the label. Fresher is better, as olive oil is at its peak within 18-24 months of production. The label should also mention the expiration date.
  • Scrutinize the Label Carefully read the label, looking for terms like "extra virgin" or "virgin" to ensure you're getting higher-quality oil. Avoid terms like "refined" or "light" if you desire the full flavor of olive oil.
  • Consider the Country-of-Origin Different regions produce olive oils with distinct flavor profiles. Greek oils tend to be grassy and peppery, Spanish oils tend to be fruity and robust, while Italian oils may have a more herbal or grassy taste. Experiment with different origins to find your favorite.
  • Balance Price and Quality While price can indicate quality, it's not the sole determining factor. High-quality olive oil is an investment, worth it for both flavor and health benefits. Find a balance between your budget and priorities.
  • Proper Storage Once you've made your selection, store the olive oil in a cool, dark place, away from direct sunlight and heat, to preserve its quality for as long as possible.
Now that you've expertly chosen the ideal olive oil for your culinary needs, it's time to put it to good use in your kitchen. Your selection, whether it's the robust extra virgin olive oil or a milder variety, will play a significant role in enhancing the flavors of your dishes. In the upcoming section, we'll provide you with valuable tips and techniques on how to cook with your chosen olive oil, ensuring your meals are infused with exceptional taste and quality.


Cooking with Olive Oil

Now that you've found the perfect olive oil, it's time to use it in your kitchen. Here are some tips for cooking with olive oil:

Enhance Dishes with EVOO: Drizzle extra virgin olive oil over salads, vegetables, and pasta dishes as a finishing touch. Its fruity and peppery notes can elevate your meals' flavor.

Marinades and Dressings: Olive oil serves as an excellent base for marinades and salad dressings, complementing a wide range of ingredients.

Baking: In baking, olive oil can be a healthy substitute for butter, adding a unique depth of flavor to pastries and cakes.

Pair with Foods: Experiment with different olive oils to complement your dishes. Robust EVOOs pair well with hearty foods, while milder virgin oils suit more delicate recipes.

Final Note 

Navigating the world of olive oil might initially seem daunting, but with a little knowledge, you can confidently choose the right oil for your cooking and health needs. Remember to check labels for quality grades, consider the flavor profiles of different origins, and store your olive oil properly to maintain its integrity. Whether you want to enhance your culinary creations, promote heart health, or savor the unique flavors of olive oil, this guide will help you make an informed decision the next time you pick up a bottle from the grocery store shelf. Olive oil is not just a condiment; it's a cornerstone of many cuisines and a key ingredient in a healthier, tastier lifestyle.

Take your time, explore the diverse options available, and savor the liquid gold that is olive oil.



Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.